A randomised trial of an intensive physiotherapy program for patients in intensive care [commentary]

AuthorBerney, SC.
TypeJournal Article (Original Research)
JournalJournal of Physiotherapy
PubMed ID26947004
Year of Publication2016
Download 2016_July_Berney.pdf (80.9 KB)
Survivors of acute respiratory failure requiring intensive care unit (ICU) admission and mechanical ventilation frequently suffer enduring impairments of physical function.1 To date, no trial, including that of Moss and colleagues, which commenced an intervention during hospitalisation, has impacted performance-based measures of physical function after hospital discharge. The authors are to be applauded for conducting a trial with high treatment fidelity, and that achieved separation and sample size, as these elements have not always been achieved in rehabilitation trials.2 and 3 However, the results must be viewed with caution. Firstly, the primary outcome (Physical Functional Performance Test score) is not validated in critical illness survivors. The test exhibited a substantial floor effect at the primary time point, with a completion rate of 33% of participants. This increased to 48% at 3 months and 43% at 6 months. Furthermore, as measured by the short form of the Continuous Scale Physical Functional Performance Test score, two participants achieved functional independence on completion of physiotherapy treatment (both in the control group), despite 50% of participants being discharged home. Secondly, a significant between-group difference in age was observed and, although not significant, the intervention group were weaker, had lower bed mobility scores and completed less available rehabilitation days in ICU than the standard care arm, suggesting important differences may have been present at randomisation. Thirdly, although described as an early intervention, intensive treatment was not initiated until a median of 8 days (IQR 6 to 11). Despite the results of this and other rehabilitation trials for critical illness survivors, these studies consistently report a perilous state of physical function beyond hospital discharge.1 and 2 It is important that we continue to seek interventions to improve these outcomes. However, the results of the AVERT trial3 are a salient reminder that we don't yet understand the who, when and how of rehabilitation for survivors of critical illness.


< More publications


Each year in Australia 260 people sustain a SCI, with over half losing full function in their arms and legs (quadriplegia). In addition to the primary disability, there is a very high rate of Obstructive...

Notch monitoring in sleepNOTCH MONITORING IN SLEEP

Sleep apnea is a condition where breathing is abnormal during sleep. There are two main forms of sleep apnea: obstructive and central. For obstructive sleep apnea, breathing is reduced because the airway...

IBAS Director Anna Burke unveiling of her portrait at Canberra's Parliament HouseIBAS DIRECTOR ANNA BURKE UNVEILING OF HER PORTRAIT AT CANBERRA'S PARLIAMENT HOUSE

Anna Burke had barely got into the swing of her speech at the unveiling of her portrait at Canberra's Parliament House when the ringing of bells caused half her audience to hurry away

Thunderstorm asthma expected to return in 2017THUNDERSTORM ASTHMA EXPECTED TO RETURN IN 2017

The Morning Show - Thunderstorm asthma expected to return in 2017. The Daily Edition - Thunderstorm Asthma is an unexpected killer. Better Health Channel - Thunderstorm asthma explained. Professor Christine McDonald

National study offers hope for breathlessnessNATIONAL STUDY OFFERS HOPE FOR BREATHLESSNESS

A national medication study is aiming to help thousands of Australians who struggle every day with shortness of breath

Helping Victorians breathe and sleep easy - A New Centre of Excellence in Respiratory and Sleep MedicineHELPING VICTORIANS BREATHE AND SLEEP EASY - A NEW CENTRE OF EXCELLENCE IN RESPIRATORY AND SLEEP MEDICINE

With your support we will build a life-changing Centre of Excellence in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine, improving quality of life and health outcomes for Victorians who struggle to breathe and sleep

Institute for Breathing and Sleep

Bowen Centre, Austin Hospital
145 Studley Road
Heidelberg, Victoria, 3084

(03) 9496 5390

Email Us